Welcome Guest

Sign In | Register

We can agree to disagree

Posted on: April 29, 2025 at 07:47:20 CT

Genco98 MU

Posts:

15098

Member For:

6.01 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

2

I have zero sentimentality to this. But you can't play teams and count the wins toward your playoff berth and resume and then exclude them from any chance at the playoffs. I get they want the committee and the subjectivity. I think it is ridiculous but if you do that you have to have an OBJECTIVE way to allow the "lesser" teams to get in. I get you think they don't "deserve" getting in but then to me - stop playing them. If they did that I would have no issue with excluding them.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

SEC & Big 10 with 26 of 32 first round selections - El Zorro MU - 4/25 12:21:39

i'm not sure why people continue to pretend there are 5 - phrejd STL - 4/25 12:32:37

RE: i'm not sure why people continue to pretend there are 5 - Ragarm MU - 4/25 16:10:40

You can't have it both ways is the issue - Genco98 MU - 4/25 13:04:51

that is 100% not true - phrejd STL - 4/25 13:18:11

I simply disagree with all of that - Genco98 MU - 4/25 14:44:01

With 2 conferences there is no committee(nm) - phrejd STL - 4/25 15:38:50

but they won’t do that - Genco98 MU - 4/25 15:59:12

And we absolutely "paid" those teams - phrejd STL - 4/25 15:55:49

It does seem that cutting out a majority of the colleges & - JeffB MU

- 4/25 14:13:19

A handful of programs have a shot today - phrejd STL - 4/25 15:37:52

So you are calling for an expansion of the SEC & the B1G. - JeffB MU

- 4/25 17:44:38

It’s a moot point - Genco98 MU - 4/25 18:00:21

Why would that matter? Playing a Sun Belt team now counts - JeffB MU

- 4/25 18:08:43

It’s simple if you play them and you count the victories - Genco98 MU - 4/25 18:49:37

They *do* count. Perhaps one way to structure things - JeffB MU

- 4/25 22:08:30

I’m not sure I follow that post - Genco98 MU - 4/26 06:42:53

There will be flaws with any way of picking teams. But - JeffB MU

- 4/26 15:20:01

But the simple one is winning your conference - Genco98 MU - 4/26 15:29:36

So have 16 conferences? But is that fair if one conference - JeffB MU

- 4/26 15:34:38

No just a system like is now - Genco98 MU - 4/26 16:44:06

How many conferences are you putting in? Are teams - JeffB MU

- 4/26 16:51:32

Maybe I’m not following you - Genco98 MU - 4/26 17:27:10

yeah, I'm kinda jumpin' around a bit, but on the other - JeffB MU

- 4/26 18:07:47

“Doesn’t deserve them” - Genco98 MU - 4/27 09:11:01

I think your hybrid championship selection system (the - JeffB MU

- 4/27 22:53:25

We can agree to disagree - Genco98 MU - 4/29 07:47:20

of course - Genco98 MU - 4/25 16:02:00

you must not have watched espn spewing sec all night(nm) - tmcats KSU - 4/25 12:26:42

©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy About Tigerboard