Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

if a school, say Vanderbilt, wants to allow a non-student to

Posted on: December 19, 2024 at 18:21:07 CT
zounami MU
Posts:
72138
Member For:
11.19 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
compete for one of its sports teams – court decisions in similar cases have indicated that they would be allowed to do so.

They could argue that the NCAA is a collusion between universities to hinder the free markets. That argument has been successful in other eligibility challenges (e.g. pro vs amateur), so why not this?

It seems logical to only allow students to compete on the teams, but the courts consider the law (e.g. antitrust statutes) rather than what's logical. That's why college sports is currently such a mess.






Edited by zounami at 18:26:04 on 12/19/24
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

does the NCAA have legal grounds to deny eligibility?... - zounami MU - 12/19 16:58:41
     NCAA :Membership Is Voluntary, By Joining a School . . . - ScottsdaleTiger MU - 12/19 20:47:30
          but the NCAA has no legal basis to enforce that authority - zounami MU - 12/19 21:07:12
               IT'S DADGUM COLLUSION!!!!1 - Mothball MU - 12/19 22:06:24
                    You're a clueless idiot. From Stanford's IEPR & other... - zounami MU - 12/20 01:24:02
     MU is put on probation.........nm - tigertix MU - 12/19 18:20:49
     No I would test it(nm) - DevilsAdvocate KC - 12/19 18:20:42
          I would as well. (nm) - zounami MU - 12/19 18:21:20
     Most likely a lawsuit would allow someone to play... - BowlBoundTiger MU - 12/19 18:12:06
          if a school, say Vanderbilt, wants to allow a non-student to - zounami MU - 12/19 18:21:07
               But has participating in intercollegiate athletics been... - BowlBoundTiger MU - 12/19 18:35:11
     RE: does the NCAA have legal grounds to deny eligibility?... - Ragarm MU - 12/19 17:47:38
          I think your point is that the NCAA should have the right to - zounami MU - 12/19 18:00:10
     RE: does the NCAA have legal grounds to deny eligibility?... - sks MU - 12/19 17:32:19
          This is 100% correct. They let the toothpaste out of the - Carlos Rossi KC - 12/19 17:40:32
     RE: does the NCAA have legal grounds to deny eligibility?... - sks MU - 12/19 17:32:13
          but wait... what good will a CBA do the NCAA if the players - zounami MU - 12/19 17:41:17
     Dennis Gates has legal rights to - Carlos Rossi KC - 12/19 17:18:53
          c'mon... more civility, less ZDS (nm) - zounami MU - 12/19 17:40:17
               Nothing vulgar about that post. He’s just giving you some - Carlos Rossi KC - 12/19 17:43:23
                    it's a manifestation of your severe ZDS (nm) - zounami MU - 12/19 17:53:18
     of course this is what it's coming down to ... - tmcats KSU - 12/19 17:07:46
          "a favorable judgement like the Vandy QB won this week"... - zounami MU - 12/19 17:39:41
               The NCAA is a very "antitrust" organization... - BowlBoundTiger MU - 12/19 18:19:18
                    legally, yes... you're absolutely right (nm) - zounami MU - 12/19 18:21:40
                         ...and that's why it needs exemptions from Congress (nm) - zounami MU - 12/19 18:21:56
     NCAA is just a name now, they have zero ability to - ADelpiero10 MU - 12/19 17:07:23
          an association of academics ... - tmcats KSU - 12/19 17:09:14




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard