Welcome Guest

So a small child who has only ever lived in us where they

Posted on: October 31, 2018 at 09:17:17 CT

El-ahrairah BAMA

Posts:

50606

Member For:

22.29 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

Were born needs to apply for citizenship, do legal paperwork, present their case, and hope for the best to have the rights guaranteed in the constitution?

Sounds unreasonable

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

You lefties who have suddenly embraced the constitution - - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:04:49

Wasn't that meant to exclude the children of diplomats? - Mormad MU - 10/31 09:29:27

RE: You lefties who have suddenly embraced the constitution - - playhard NWMSU - 10/31 08:22:06

We had this debate in 1868 - El-ahrairah BAMA - 10/31 08:17:43

So GAT would have first hand knowledge of this(nm) - playhard NWMSU - 10/31 08:26:16

And take notes when I speak.(nm) - GA Tiger MU - 10/31 09:08:24

the author is incorrect and dishonest. he included - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:21:27

that's not the issue. - gmmm98 MU

- 10/31 08:30:38

Of course it is. What, pray tell, do you consider the issue - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:35:39

nice wall of irrelevant text(nm) - gmmm98 MU

- 10/31 08:53:47

It's just the issue surrounding the 14th. If you find it - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:56:38

so you're going to interpret constitutional language - gmmm98 MU

- 10/31 09:06:22

Implied? There's written records - Kaw-djer - 10/31 09:13:00

he can't be bothered by reading a useless wall of - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:15:51

Uh, what was implied 150 yrs ago IS THE DAMN CONSTITUTION - GA Tiger MU - 10/31 09:10:11

this doesn't even make sense - gmmm98 MU

- 10/31 09:14:43

do you have a position or statement here to make? a - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:17:04

you don't know anything about constitutional construction - gmmm98 MU

- 10/31 09:39:32

and thanks for never offering an argument on the - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:51:28

there is NO argument, is the thing - gmmm98 MU

- 10/31 13:17:15

Feel better? You may as well have said that into a mirror. (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:49:46

sad, isn't it? (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:10:34

why have scotus if interpreting meaning of words written - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:07:50

What do you think SCOTUS will do? I don't need to - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:07:10

So a newborn in America isn’t a citizen here - El-ahrairah BAMA - 10/31 08:24:01

Moreover, do you think that child would NOT be a citizen of - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:39:38

1. It means they are a citizen of the country to which thei - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:38:15

So a small child who has only ever lived in us where they - El-ahrairah BAMA - 10/31 09:17:17

If the parents are citizens of another country, they aren't - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:18:24

But they aren’t really citizens - El-ahrairah BAMA - 10/31 10:00:16

what they are or aren't fleeing isn't the question - and its - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 10:15:11

The messy lie of citizenship and statism (nm) - Kaw-djer - 10/31 08:25:48

Same bigoted arguments today - MrBlueSky MU - 10/31 08:20:39

this issue hasn't anything to do with skin color nor ethnici - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:40:26

Lol, it absolutely does. And you're being purposely - MrBlueSky MU - 10/31 08:50:17

No, you're projecting upon millions of others the thinking a - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:03:03

No, like with most things when your side cannot persuade - DHighlander NWMSU - 10/31 08:59:27

At the end of every thread, you get this. "no, you're just. - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 09:08:34

RE: Same bigoted arguments today - None**** MU - 10/31 08:31:57

Illegal immigrants can't vote, schmuck. (nm) - MrBlueSky MU - 10/31 08:32:41

But their American born children can. Schmuck!(nm) - DHighlander NWMSU - 10/31 08:47:18

Well, they would be citizens, right? - MrBlueSky MU - 10/31 08:49:21

What is the right way? You don't need to amend the constitu - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:57:50

Would they? You do realize that is the topic at hand don't - DHighlander NWMSU - 10/31 08:56:57

RE: Illegal immigrants can't vote, schmuck. (nm) - None**** MU - 10/31 08:41:18

Link? - MrBlueSky MU - 10/31 08:46:17

You have an extraordinary amount of white guilt that - hokie VT - 10/31 08:31:22

Who did I call racist? I said the arguments being made - MrBlueSky MU - 10/31 08:33:55

that's a false statement, as none of the arguments made - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:42:22

The arguments in 1868 against the 14th amendment - MrBlueSky MU - 10/31 08:45:41

No, MBS, I'm not making any of those arguments, but yet - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:49:54

Sorry, I thought your post mentioned Chinamen, mongoloid, - hokie VT - 10/31 08:39:57

False - although those arguments were held, they were - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:22:23

did I say those arguments won out? - MrBlueSky MU - 10/31 08:25:19

I'm not of an ilk here, sport. Lumping me with anyone - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:45:00

You're the only person on this board making reference to the - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:44:16

The author is incorrect (nm) - Kaw-djer - 10/31 08:19:21

5-4 upholding birthright citizenship. Roberts playing role - Emoji Man MSU - 10/31 08:16:30

Devil's advocate, is a newborn under the jurisdiction of the - TheWildcat STL - 10/31 08:15:37

No. No one is (nm) - Kaw-djer - 10/31 08:19:42

yes. If you and your wife are in Spain on vacation and she - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:17:16

What if a mom was on an extended sexual tourism tour of - Emoji Man MSU - 10/31 08:22:09

RE: What if a mom was on an extended sexual tourism tour of - 90Tiger MU - 10/31 08:23:17