Welcome Guest
Sign In | Register

"saving millions of lives both American and Japanese" is

Posted on: September 5, 2017 at 10:40:01 CT
90Tiger STL
Posts:
160804
Member For:
23.21 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
a myth propagated by those who dropped the bomb.

If the US would have pulled back, what war was Japan capable of waging?

You're assuming the US would have "had" to invade mainland Japan or "had" to have an unconditional surrender. Neither is true.
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

On this day in 1945 Truman's atomic bomb drops forced - Malcolm Ten MU - 9/5 10:34:53
     Why didn't he nuke Korea - El-ahrairah KC - 9/5 12:01:50
          Korea was a UN Police Action, not an American operation - ScottsdaleTiger MU - 9/5 12:50:30
               Lol - pickle MU - 9/5 13:19:42
     Emoji, Ragnar, Omar...doesn't matter - pickle MU - 9/5 11:40:38
     It's amazing that the Pubs now want to save these monsters - Evenflow MU - 9/5 11:04:23
          We remade Japan in our own image - ScottsdaleTiger MU - 9/5 12:53:41
          Let Asians save themselves. What a concept.(nm) - GA Tiger MU - 9/5 11:30:36
     You have posted on wrong Board-- many believe US started WW2 - mu7176grad MU - 9/5 10:49:32
          No one here has argued the US started WWII (nm) - pickle MU - 9/5 11:39:09
          And much worse - Lincoln violated our Constitution. - GA Tiger MU - 9/5 11:31:59
               Preserving one country: - ummmm MU - 9/5 11:56:43
                    Learn history (or Geography) - Spanky KU - 9/5 12:12:26
                         Well that point went flying over your head. - ummmm MU - 9/5 12:46:54
                              A false equivalency is not a point... - Spanky KU - 9/5 14:53:45
                              yeah, you can't do anything but literal with Spanky. He - 90Tiger MU - 9/5 13:03:04
                                   Hungary was never a member of the USSR. As such, equating - Spanky KU - 9/5 13:59:34
          No rational person believes that - Spanky KU - 9/5 11:06:03
          nobody has called the Japanese govt "innocent victims" - - 90Tiger MU - 9/5 10:51:34
          The civilians living in Hiroshima and Nagasaki were indeed - ummmm MU - 9/5 10:51:14
     Should Trump drop a couple nukes on two non-capital - ummmm MU - 9/5 10:41:36
     "saving millions of lives both American and Japanese" is - 90Tiger MU - 9/5 10:40:01
          Watch Hacksaw Ridge - ScottsdaleTiger MU - 9/5 13:00:39
          it is not a myth - Malcolm Ten MU - 9/5 10:41:37
               It's a myth. Why would the US have needed to invade and co - 90Tiger MU - 9/5 10:43:29
                    To cut off the monster's head - ScottsdaleTiger MU - 9/5 12:45:16
                         those aren't the only choices, as I already pointed out. Sh - 90Tiger MU - 9/5 13:52:22
                    Did we conquer japan? Or just defeat it? The problem - hokie VT - 9/5 11:33:55
                         the question was why you think the US would have been - 90Tiger MU - 9/5 12:04:08
                    They most certainly had plans to continue the war and - Mo Texan MU - 9/5 11:10:57
                    What should they have done with Japanese soldiers elsewhere - mu7176grad MU - 9/5 11:04:38
                         US should have gone home and defended the US (nm) - 90Tiger MU - 9/5 11:18:55
                         RE: What should they have done with Japanese soldiers elsewhere - MOCO SON MU - 9/5 11:11:03
     RE: On this day in 1945 Truman's atomic bomb drops forced - MOCO SON MU - 9/5 10:37:40




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard