Welcome Guest

Should have said defensively - Mathews and Schmidt

Posted on: September 26, 2023 at 19:48:16 CT

alstl MU

Posts:

29561

Member For:

24.39 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

total package were better. Considering he played his entire career vs pitchers throwing of the higher mound Mathews has to get serious consideration for best offensively. Overshadowed somewhat by teammate Aaron.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Perhaps the best 3rd baseman of them all - RIP Brooks(nm) - alstl MU - 9/26 17:10:29

1970 World Series MVP. Batted .429 in five games, with - Mizzou Tom KC - 9/27 08:05:33

Maybe defensively, not even close in terms... - Gyro MU

- 9/26 18:01:40

Should have said defensively - Mathews and Schmidt - alstl MU - 9/26 19:48:16

Scott Rollen is a top 5 (nm) - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 9/26 19:02:49

Jim Edmonds would be top 10 if he played 3rd(nm) - CulturedDan MU

- 9/26 20:52:20

David Eckstein might be the Cardinals best short stop ever - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 9/26 21:19:18

Edgar Renteria was way better... - Gyro MU

- 9/27 07:45:00

Not sure of that. I'd put him behind Nolan and maybe - Ferg MU - 9/26 20:06:33

7x All-Star, NL Rookie of the Year, 8x Gold Glove, Silver - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 9/26 20:34:52

Pendelton too(nm) - TigerA MU - 9/26 20:17:25

Zamboni machine is in the conversation defensively(nm) - Erwin Fletcher STL - 9/27 07:49:33

no range (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 9/27 09:06:27

Robinson averaged almost .5 more chances per game - Fred G. Sanford STL - 9/27 08:37:48

I am not trying to compare Reitz to hall of famers. When - Erwin Fletcher STL - 9/27 14:44:15

Did George Brett bang your wife or something? - Carlos Rossi KC - 9/26 18:08:19

George Brett had a serious pine tar problem (nm) - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 9/26 20:37:28

slump buster(nm) - TigerA MU - 9/26 20:03:56

LMAO. If you have ever seen Gyro's wife...she is the - Carlos Rossi KC - 9/26 20:18:36

That isn’t Gyro’s wife. That is Gyro when he is in his - TigerMatt KC - 9/27 00:24:58

Does your wife have meth teeth too TigerMeth?(nm) - Gyro MU

- 9/27 07:48:53

Found your wife’s logo… - Carlos Rossi KC - 9/27 08:36:00

Congrats to you... - Gyro MU

- 9/27 08:47:12

Did you ensure she’s getting fees for using her image?(nm) - Carlos Rossi KC - 9/27 08:53:45

If I were you I'd get that... - Gyro MU

- 9/27 09:14:14

Brett was a great player - Ferg MU - 9/26 20:03:01

Keep it up Skippy(nm) - Gyro MU

- 9/26 20:02:52

I think Schmidt is pretty well regarded as #1 overall (nm) - TheWildcat MU

- 9/26 19:38:10

Sure didn’t do a whole lot in the post season. Brett - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 19:53:19

Schmidt won a world series in 1980 against the Royals and - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 19:57:03

I was going to say if I was starting a team of best - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 19:44:08

.237, 4 hrs in 36 postseason games. Meh(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 19:59:24

Dumb (nm) - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:12:25

Why is that dumb? Schmidt was the best 3rd baseman ever but - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 20:18:13

OK it's not dumb, but seems a bit on the petty side. (nm) - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:53:21

He won a world series and was mvp. You remember - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:24:43

So, you base his whole career on 36 games? - Hickeytime MU

- 9/26 20:06:27

You think he has Lou Brock as the best left fielder ever.(nm) - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:15:49

Ted Williams, and yes, he stunk in his only WS(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 20:16:55

Did i say that?(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 20:07:05

Pretty much. Yes (nm) - Hickeytime MU

- 9/26 21:19:06

Nope(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/27 10:51:22

RE: .237, 4 hrs in 36 postseason games. Meh(nm) - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:05:44

RE: .237, 4 hrs in 36 postseason games. Meh(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 20:06:38

Koepka is preparing for the Ryder Cup - Sal CMSU - 9/26 17:12:36

SMH - fatrat MU - 9/26 20:04:41