Welcome Guest

I was going to say if I was starting a team of best

Posted on: September 26, 2023 at 19:44:08 CT

Uncle John STL

Posts:

77317

Member For:

19.48 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

players in their prime Schmidt would be my pick at 3rd. I'd probably take Brett next. I think Arenado is the best defensive 3rd baseman I've seen. It was BR for a long time.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Perhaps the best 3rd baseman of them all - RIP Brooks(nm) - alstl MU - 9/26 17:10:29

1970 World Series MVP. Batted .429 in five games, with - Mizzou Tom KC - 9/27 08:05:33

Maybe defensively, not even close in terms... - Gyro MU

- 9/26 18:01:40

Should have said defensively - Mathews and Schmidt - alstl MU - 9/26 19:48:16

Scott Rollen is a top 5 (nm) - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 9/26 19:02:49

Jim Edmonds would be top 10 if he played 3rd(nm) - CulturedDan MU

- 9/26 20:52:20

David Eckstein might be the Cardinals best short stop ever - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 9/26 21:19:18

Edgar Renteria was way better... - Gyro MU

- 9/27 07:45:00

Not sure of that. I'd put him behind Nolan and maybe - Ferg MU - 9/26 20:06:33

7x All-Star, NL Rookie of the Year, 8x Gold Glove, Silver - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 9/26 20:34:52

Pendelton too(nm) - TigerA MU - 9/26 20:17:25

Zamboni machine is in the conversation defensively(nm) - Erwin Fletcher STL - 9/27 07:49:33

no range (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 9/27 09:06:27

Robinson averaged almost .5 more chances per game - Fred G. Sanford STL - 9/27 08:37:48

I am not trying to compare Reitz to hall of famers. When - Erwin Fletcher STL - 9/27 14:44:15

Did George Brett bang your wife or something? - Carlos Rossi KC - 9/26 18:08:19

George Brett had a serious pine tar problem (nm) - KCT-BoneTiger MU

- 9/26 20:37:28

slump buster(nm) - TigerA MU - 9/26 20:03:56

LMAO. If you have ever seen Gyro's wife...she is the - Carlos Rossi KC - 9/26 20:18:36

That isn’t Gyro’s wife. That is Gyro when he is in his - TigerMatt KC - 9/27 00:24:58

Does your wife have meth teeth too TigerMeth?(nm) - Gyro MU

- 9/27 07:48:53

Found your wife’s logo… - Carlos Rossi KC - 9/27 08:36:00

Congrats to you... - Gyro MU

- 9/27 08:47:12

Did you ensure she’s getting fees for using her image?(nm) - Carlos Rossi KC - 9/27 08:53:45

If I were you I'd get that... - Gyro MU

- 9/27 09:14:14

Brett was a great player - Ferg MU - 9/26 20:03:01

Keep it up Skippy(nm) - Gyro MU

- 9/26 20:02:52

I think Schmidt is pretty well regarded as #1 overall (nm) - TheWildcat MU

- 9/26 19:38:10

Sure didn’t do a whole lot in the post season. Brett - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 19:53:19

Schmidt won a world series in 1980 against the Royals and - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 19:57:03

I was going to say if I was starting a team of best - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 19:44:08

.237, 4 hrs in 36 postseason games. Meh(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 19:59:24

Dumb (nm) - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:12:25

Why is that dumb? Schmidt was the best 3rd baseman ever but - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 20:18:13

OK it's not dumb, but seems a bit on the petty side. (nm) - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:53:21

He won a world series and was mvp. You remember - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:24:43

So, you base his whole career on 36 games? - Hickeytime MU

- 9/26 20:06:27

You think he has Lou Brock as the best left fielder ever.(nm) - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:15:49

Ted Williams, and yes, he stunk in his only WS(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 20:16:55

Did i say that?(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 20:07:05

Pretty much. Yes (nm) - Hickeytime MU

- 9/26 21:19:06

Nope(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/27 10:51:22

RE: .237, 4 hrs in 36 postseason games. Meh(nm) - Uncle John MU

- 9/26 20:05:44

RE: .237, 4 hrs in 36 postseason games. Meh(nm) - tigerNkc KC - 9/26 20:06:38

Koepka is preparing for the Ryder Cup - Sal CMSU - 9/26 17:12:36

SMH - fatrat MU - 9/26 20:04:41