Welcome Guest

Sign In | Register

The real problem here is that the founding documents were

Posted on: June 30, 2022 at 11:40:07 CT

DHighlander NWMSU

Posts:

46326

Member For:

15.74 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

0

written using a very political give and take process. To get the original states to ratify the constitution required a number of deals and concessions and the wording used was very important.

Just because a particular participant made notes of the process does not mean that his beliefs are what was finally agreed to. The Federalist Papers and similar documents were written from the perspective of a single side. If you read Clarence Thomas' personal notes about how they came to the recent SC decisions I suspect they read very differently than Soto Mayor's. What matters is the ultimate decision they made not the individual position papers they may write.

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

If someone MEANS TO WRITE that "the car is red" but - hokie VT - 6/30 11:30:40

The real problem here is that the founding documents were - DHighlander NWMSU - 6/30 11:40:07

You said it better than i did. nm - hokie VT - 6/30 11:48:32

The plain meaning of the Constitution is paramount - Wilco MU - 6/30 11:47:39

No, just like with laws the wording is all that matters. - DHighlander NWMSU - 6/30 11:55:48

then that clause only applies to the 13 original States - cnk ATL - 6/30 12:06:06

in that case, you can forget the 2A - ashtray UF - 6/30 12:00:04

Can you show that Migration had a different meaning when - DHighlander NWMSU - 6/30 12:07:35

it's already been shown.. you just choose to ignore it - ashtray UF - 6/30 12:08:22

No, that was the intent of a modern day - DHighlander NWMSU - 6/30 13:00:29

incorrect - ashtray UF - 6/30 13:05:17

It also could literally mean a right to "bear arms" - ummmm MU - 6/30 12:01:41

intent doesn't matter, according to DH - ashtray UF - 6/30 12:02:50

Welp, I just ordered a pair of bear arms - kmawv8 MU - 6/30 12:04:48

You aren’t listening (nm) - Wilco MU - 6/30 11:59:13

I'm listening, but as usual your opinions do not matter to - DHighlander NWMSU - 6/30 12:03:51

You aren’t listening - Wilco MU - 6/30 12:08:18

yes there is a way - ashtray UF - 6/30 12:04:53

So you have the personal notes of every single person - DHighlander NWMSU - 6/30 12:09:26

the debates? Yes, they are easily searchable - ashtray UF - 6/30 12:10:47

Every single debate that took place on the floor of every - DHighlander NWMSU - 6/30 13:04:01

that's not how it worked - ashtray UF - 6/30 13:05:40

Intent is all that matters. - ummmm MU - 6/30 11:58:33

The legislative debates were recorded - Wilco MU - 6/30 11:37:39

And they ultimately decided on the wording that was - DHighlander NWMSU - 6/30 11:46:13

The debates are windows - Wilco MU - 6/30 11:48:32

And you get them from the perspective of the person who - DHighlander NWMSU - 6/30 11:59:48

You aren’t listening - Wilco MU - 6/30 12:02:07

The point of contracts (or compacts) is to reduce the intent - ummmm MU - 6/30 11:35:32

You may have noticed that a lot of the idiots on this board - hokie VT - 6/30 11:43:42

This doesn't appear to address what I just said. (nm) - ummmm MU - 6/30 11:47:58

it's what he does after he's twisted himself into a pretzel - ashtray UF - 6/30 12:02:02

You’re doing it again. Try taking my advice (nm) - Wilco MU - 6/30 11:46:10

He had never heard of this clause before today. - ummmm MU - 6/30 11:47:40

I know. It’s just sad that he can’t allow himself - Wilco MU - 6/30 11:49:17

©2024 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy About Tigerboard