Welcome Guest

That's the wrong question

Posted on: May 19, 2020 at 12:19:32 CT

BigDave MU

Posts:

8213

Member For:

25.77 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

The Constitution grants certain rights to the government. You have to show where it says the government has been enumerated that right in the Constitution. Those rights not enumerated are reserved by the people, or state (10th Amendment).

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

Dershowitz: ‘You Have No Right to Not Be Vaccinated,’ - JeffB MU

- 5/19 10:29:09

Constitutional Basis of Mandatory Vaccination - CDC summary - JeffB MU

- 5/19 12:24:31

I don't like it, but he's right. - dangertim MU

- 5/19 11:22:18

That's the wrong question - BigDave MU - 5/19 12:19:32

I respect this opinion(nm) - dangertim MU

- 5/19 12:46:12

self-ownership (nm) - pickle MU

- 5/19 11:42:03

uh...wut? (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 5/19 12:39:20

are you talking natural or constitutional right of self - dangertim MU

- 5/19 11:47:01

natural right (nm) - pickle MU

- 5/19 11:54:24

I agree. I don't think the lawyer above is an expert in - dangertim MU

- 5/19 11:55:41

What happened to - Wildcat KSU - 5/19 11:33:23

LOL. The right for the government to inject something into - North co-co champs MU - 5/19 11:30:13

there’s flouride in the water supply (nm) - pickle MU

- 5/19 11:54:54

as ashtray, the government doesn't have rights. They are - dangertim MU

- 5/19 11:36:54

Technically he's right. The citizens have guaranteed rights - North co-co champs MU - 5/19 11:41:08

government doesn't have rights - ashtray UF - 5/19 11:31:40

I agree with that... or at the very least, they only have - North co-co champs MU - 5/19 11:38:16

The burden of proof is on those who think the state has a - JeffB MU

- 5/19 11:29:07

SCOTUS has decided gvmt has the right to do so - pickle MU

- 5/19 11:43:12

this isn't a criminal trial. What do you mean burden of - dangertim MU

- 5/19 11:37:34

The 'burden of proof' is not exclusive to criminal trials. - JeffB MU

- 5/19 11:40:40

Property right, right to your own body. If this is true, th - 90Tiger STL - 5/19 11:28:52

a needle in the arm is not a tracker. I could argue - dangertim MU

- 5/19 11:39:04

RE: a needle in the arm is not a tracker. I could argue - 90Tiger STL - 5/19 12:42:51

and if i don't want the contents of the needle - whether a - 90Tiger STL - 5/19 12:40:11

what if I don't want a vaccine? - ashtray UF - 5/19 11:39:50

I'm with you bud, but we're talking about - dangertim MU

- 5/19 11:41:42

i disagree - pickle MU

- 5/19 12:42:45

I get it - constitutional v. natural right discussion. no s - 90Tiger STL - 5/19 12:41:14

rights aren't granted by the Constitution - ashtray UF - 5/19 11:43:22

see this - 90Tiger STL - 5/19 12:41:41

I agree. Is derpowitz talking natural rights?(nm) - dangertim MU

- 5/19 11:46:38

I don't listen to anything he says, so I have no idea (nm) - ashtray UF - 5/19 11:48:22

you may wish to go back to START then (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 5/19 12:42:08

that requires me to read another JeffB link - ashtray UF - 5/19 13:41:16

I didn't read it either. ^5(nm) - dangertim MU

- 5/19 11:54:08

I don't either (nm) - Sal MU

- 5/19 11:31:51

Derpowitz - JG A - 5/19 11:19:23

So much for My Body, My Choice (nm) - mizzouSECedes STL - 5/19 10:53:30

Quite the contradiction, huh?(nm) - 4TigersinMichigan MU - 5/19 11:17:32

only if he’s ever made that argument (nm) - pickle MU

- 5/19 12:05:23

he’s right (nm) - pickle MU

- 5/19 10:46:00

articulate the position, I don't get it. he's not arguing t - 90Tiger STL - 5/19 11:27:35

Do you understand English? - JG A - 5/19 11:18:34

This guy is nuts, first he defends DJT from the tyranny of - tigertix MU - 5/19 10:31:44

'citizens have “no right” to refuse to wear a mask or refuse - JeffB MU

- 5/19 10:34:29

He's a hack that will say whatever he's paid to - ashtray UF - 5/19 10:30:48

You're 1000% spot on....nm - tigertix MU - 5/19 10:32:14