Welcome Guest

Good luck with your struggle! Without the current

Posted on: August 30, 2017 at 21:54:33 CT
STL1DFW STL
Posts:
56617
Member For:
16.61 yrs
Level:
User
M.O.B. Votes:
0
ability to time travel, best I might be able to offer could start with this & hopefully in the spirit of good sportsmanship it can end, since this ss a rather all time, history of humankind type of over encompassing topic that could last the rest of the history of humankind.

I don't expect you to understand spirit, since you seems to be unaware or familiar with possessing it, but for the sake of discussion:

"The first comes from the Babylonian Talmud 43a. Babylonian Talmud (late first or second century AD) Babylonian Sanhedrin43a-b “On the eve of the Passover they hanged Yeshu and the herald went before him for forty days saying [Yeshu] is going forth to be stoned in that he hate practiced sorcery and beguiled and led astray Israel Here Jesus is accused of sorcery, in obvious parallel with the charge leveled in Matthew 12:22-23. The writer of the Talmud does not agree that Jesus worked bona fide miracles, but he reports that he did things which, to the enemy of Jesus could only be written off as sorcery. Also, in Babylonian Sanhedrin107b it is claimed that Jesus practiced magic. In tHul2:22-23 it is reported that healings were done in the name of Jesus. So we have indirect confirmation of the crucifixion of Jesus and of his working of public miracles-only charging that the miracles were worked by Satan, not God.

The point I would make from this material in the Jewish Talmud from the late first century is that it proves that Jesus was a person they felt they had to deal with and that it was sufficiently common knowledge that he worked signs and wonders that they felt they had to address this by claiming that Jesus did his miracles by the power of Satan (sorcery). Does this “prove” that Jesus worked miracles? Maybe or maybe not. What it proves is that many in his day were convinced that he worked miracles and that his enemies were aware of sufficient positive evidence of this that they felt they needed to explain it.

My second example of a first century writer who accidentally provided evidence of the miraculous events surrounding Jesus comes from the writer Thallus. We know of Thallus only from a third century Christian historian named Julius Africanus who wrote a three-volume treatise of world history. According Julius, Thallus wrote in what we consider the 50s AD. In discussion the darkness at the time of the resurrection of Jesus, Julius Africanus mentions that in the 3rd book of Thallus’ history, he mentions the darkness and calls it an eclipse of the sun. Africanus believes that Thallus is wrong (ie he is wrong that this was due to an eclipse). Whether or not this source proves the darkness at the time If Jesus’ crucifixion is debatable, but it does seem to support the idea that even non-Christians were aware of the resurrection as early as the 50s AD-at about the time the first book of the NT was written. It also supports the claim, not necessarily of the darkness having occurred, but of the darkness having been claimed and believed by the Christians. By the way, we have access to information that Julius Africanus did not. Using modern astronomical measurements,we can determine when total or near total eclipses of the sun occurred thousands of years in the past. It is a fact that there was no solar eclipse which is even a reasonable candidate to be a natural explanation of the darkness at the time Jesus died. As with the Talmud evidence, the source of the material is not trying to prove that a miracle happened, but he is trying to explain extant data which was common knowledge in a way consistent with his unbelief.

In summary, the request for “proof” in written documents that Jesus did in fact work miracles from non-believers is, logically, a very high bar indeed. We can assume that most of those who witnessed his miracles either came to believe in him or found ways to explain away what they saw. In fact, I believe that it is striking that we have these two documented examples of non-Christians–the writers of the Talmud and Thallus–feeling the need to explain what seems to have been a common knowledge that there was much reason to believe Jesus worked miracles."

http://evidenceforchristianity.org/is-there-any-proof-outside-the-bible-that-jesus-performed-miracles/
Report Message

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

Handle:
Password:
Subject:

MESSAGE THREAD

STL1DFW: Show me an extra biblical account - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 21:33:05
     Contemporary historians did not exist - raskolnikov MU - 8/31 08:17:09
     why would there be any account of it? The Jews and Romans - tigerinhogtown STL - 8/31 00:35:40
          That is crazy talk. So Romans wouldnt allow - TigerMatt MU - 8/31 00:59:06
     RE: STL1DFW: Show me an extra biblical account - 615Tiger STL - 8/31 00:34:53
          Nm - TigerMatt MU - 8/31 00:49:07
               Contemporary Jews see Jesus as noting of the sort... - STL1DFW STL - 8/31 03:02:29
               RE: None of that proves the claim Jesus is God - 615Tiger STL - 8/31 01:00:41
                    Nm - TigerMatt MU - 8/31 01:47:53
     How about some contemporary examples of miracles? - JeffB MU - 8/30 22:00:34
          The Lourdes Medical Cures Revisited† - JeffB MU - 8/30 22:11:21
               Should be testable, right? Where are the - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 22:33:47
                    Yes, there are many examples of cures 'unexplainable by - JeffB MU - 8/30 22:39:40
                         Nm - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 22:59:41
                              You are way oversimplifying. If it was a single case of some - JeffB MU - 8/31 08:59:45
          The Shroud of Turin and the Facts... - JeffB MU - 8/30 22:06:40
               Lol.. long debunked(nm) - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 22:19:54
                    No. Scientists have revisited earlier conclusions. - JeffB MU - 8/30 22:21:34
                         Have you studied the tahara? A jew would never have been - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 22:56:26
                              I don't think you have read much about it. There IS a - JeffB MU - 8/31 09:04:30
                              Pure conjecture(nm) - STL1DFW STL - 8/31 00:56:56
                                   Documented history, unlike your fairy tales.(nm) - TigerMatt MU - 8/31 01:00:30
                                        You've made up some fairy tales alright to try & cope.. - STL1DFW STL - 8/31 02:06:40
                         Careful. He'll want you to spoon feed all of it to him(nm) - STL1DFW STL - 8/30 22:27:07
          Eucharistic miracles have left physical evidenice in a - JeffB MU - 8/30 22:03:36
               I can find sites saying bigfoot is real. So what? - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 23:12:48
     Start here monkey-butt 🐵..... - mattieo86 MU - 8/30 21:58:19
          Nothing contemporary. Bringing up crucifixion darkness - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 23:59:29
     Good luck with your struggle! Without the current - STL1DFW STL - 8/30 21:54:33
          Lol... so stupid.(nm) - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 21:57:14
               I'm convinced you are. You don't have to plead with me - STL1DFW STL - 8/30 22:00:33
     RE: STL1DFW: Show me an extra biblical account - Uncle Fester USMC - 8/30 21:45:24
     Luke 16:31 - TigerFan92 MU - 8/30 21:42:08
          Why would I believe the bible over Homer's - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 21:54:07
               ^^Yes, he's this dumb(nm) - STL1DFW STL - 8/30 22:01:46
          People die for lies, but they believe them to be true. - MizzouTigerz MU - 8/30 21:53:36
               A lot of true believers die. That isnt proof - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 21:55:54
                    umm they died for what they literally saw(nm) - TigerFan92 MU - 8/31 11:12:15
          Extrabiblical means "outside the Bible". nm - SparkyStalcup MU - 8/30 21:42:59
               You will never be convinced. Enjoy - TigerFan92 MU - 8/30 21:44:40
     God doesn't have to prove anything to you. - MizzouTigerz MU - 8/30 21:40:08
          then why do you spend your life providing justifications, ev - 90Tiger MU - 8/30 21:57:17
               Why are you threatened by it & always feel a need to attack - STL1DFW STL - 8/30 22:07:29
                    Christianity is founded on faith, but bizarre people like - TigerMatt MU - 8/31 02:00:59
                         Now you're just lashing out & projecting after failing so - STL1DFW STL - 8/31 02:12:46
          Nm - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 21:49:55
               What part of End of discussion. did you not understand? - MizzouTigerz MU - 8/30 21:54:54
                    Typical tuck tail and run.(nm) - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 21:56:15
                         It's really more a case of you failing miserably(nm) - STL1DFW STL - 8/30 22:18:04
                              You hsvent offered a shred of evidence.(nm) - TigerMatt MU - 8/31 00:01:00
                                   I proved it rather quickly & easily. The rest has been just - STL1DFW STL - 8/31 00:42:59
          You can't argue with religious zealots. Evidence doesn't - SparkyStalcup MU - 8/30 21:43:52
               You can't argue with Evidence - MizzouTigerz MU - 8/30 21:49:08
                    No evidence of Jesus' miracles. See my original - TigerMatt MU - 8/30 21:51:11
                         What evidence would there be if you were not present... - STL1DFW STL - 8/30 22:25:02
               And the same goes for Anti Religious Zealots - Uncle Fester USMC - 8/30 21:48:57




©2025 Fanboards L.L.C. — Our Privacy Policy   About Tigerboard