Welcome Guest

I'm not trying to debate you, just thinking out loud

Posted on: June 8, 2019 at 16:00:25 CT

cnk MU

Posts:

190246

Member For:

26.31 yrs

Level:

User

M.O.B. Votes:

and trying to follow logical strings.

If we assume that animals that are able to think have souls, the interesting question to me is then is it moral to kill creatures that have souls?

Please explain why this message is being reported.

REPLY

MESSAGE THREAD

JG, regarding thinking - cnk ATL - 6/8 15:33:11

The brain is merely a communication system - JG A - 6/8 15:36:11

lol - the "spiritual being"? is it made of matter or just en - 90Tiger STL - 6/8 15:48:39

No. energy is part of the physical universe - JG A - 6/8 15:49:32

Are our souls confined to our physical bodies?(nm) - cnk ATL - 6/8 16:02:17

No - JG A - 6/8 16:02:49

Does that mean astral projection is possible? - cnk ATL - 6/8 16:05:04

I think so - JG A - 6/8 16:07:16

so the soul isn't part of our universe? (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 6/8 15:50:56

Nope - JG A - 6/8 15:53:57

define the boundaries of the universe and then - 90Tiger STL - 6/8 15:57:15

JG is far more out there than I ever imagined.(nm) - TigerMatt STL - 6/8 15:58:14

What I have said is consistent with EVERY - JG A - 6/8 16:02:22

LOL - now there's a foundation to rest upon! (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 6/8 18:15:06

Unreal.(nm) - TigerMatt STL - 6/8 18:17:28

No.....real - JG A - 6/8 18:21:37

by what definition? (nm) - 90Tiger STL - 6/8 15:55:06

So is the human body. How does this soul interface with the - TigerMatt STL - 6/8 15:50:25

In your case - JG A - 6/8 15:54:26

Just admit you have no evidence to support your claims.(nm) - TigerMatt STL - 6/8 15:57:07

I have nothing you would believe - JG A - 6/8 16:01:38

So assuming "thinking" is something, from - GA Tiger MU - 6/8 15:45:03

If you can't figure it out (even if you don't agree) - JG A - 6/8 15:48:44

^^^ Perfect JG. Useless. Avoidance. Predictable. - GA Tiger MU - 6/8 15:50:42

So system 1 and system 2 are part of the soul? - cnk ATL - 6/8 15:40:11

Yes the soul is the controlling entity of your body - JG A - 6/8 15:41:59

Ok, so now I'm ready for the definition/explanation for - GA Tiger MU - 6/8 15:46:09

You aren't nearly as stupid as you continually act - JG A - 6/8 15:48:04

Ok, though I need not platitudes. Now..the definition.... - GA Tiger MU - 6/8 15:48:54

Do other animals that think have souls?(nm) - cnk ATL - 6/8 15:44:18

That is a matter of much debate - JG A - 6/8 15:47:08

Bees seem to be able to do simple math - cnk ATL - 6/8 15:50:18

AS I said, much debate and I have no - JG A - 6/8 15:56:12

I'm not trying to debate you, just thinking out loud - cnk ATL - 6/8 16:00:25

Another good question and matter of much debate - JG A - 6/8 16:04:56

Ok, you cannot be wrong about that because - GA Tiger MU - 6/8 16:13:14

If by never you mean by the time your body dies - JG A - 6/8 16:15:57

No. I COULD be wrong. Nuance, my boy. - GA Tiger MU - 6/8 16:22:21

You usually are(nm) - JG A - 6/8 16:23:54

Does the soul still think after leaving the body - cnk ATL - 6/8 16:19:28

Yes of course - JG A - 6/8 16:23:28

I get that it's up for debate, I'm genuinely interested in - cnk ATL - 6/8 16:07:27

AS I said I think animal "souls" are a different - JG A - 6/8 16:11:38

So what does soul have to do with intellect and IQ? - GA Tiger MU - 6/8 16:24:51

Intellect and IQ PROBABLY are also measured by - JG A - 6/8 16:27:22

Probably? It HAS to be. Its not going to - GA Tiger MU - 6/8 16:33:41

NO - JG A - 6/8 16:35:19

Does in the world I inhabit.(nm) - GA Tiger MU - 6/8 17:52:01

well you are senile. sooo......(nm) - JG A - 6/8 18:22:28

Where is the thinking done then? Where is this spiritual - TigerMatt STL - 6/8 15:37:21

In his case - 4TigersinMichigan MU - 6/8 15:39:19

I have no doubts you don't really think you are a spiritual - JG A - 6/8 15:40:35